GIS & Insurance: Transforming Risk Assessment

Formal, Professional

Formal, Professional

The convergence of Geographic Information Systems (GIS) and the insurance industry is revolutionizing risk assessment methodologies. Munich Re, a leading reinsurance company, leverages sophisticated spatial analytics for comprehensive catastrophe modeling. Property and casualty insurance providers are increasingly adopting Esri’s ArcGIS platform to visualize and analyze geographical data, improving underwriting accuracy. Climate change, a critical factor influencing insurance risk, is being analyzed through GIS to map vulnerable areas. This integration of GIS and insurance enables a more precise evaluation of risk exposure and facilitates the development of tailored insurance products.

GIS Revolutionizes Insurance Risk Assessment

The insurance industry stands at a critical juncture, facing unprecedented challenges from a confluence of escalating natural disasters, the accelerating impacts of climate change, and the emergence of novel and complex risks. Traditional methods of risk assessment, often reliant on historical data and broad statistical averages, are proving increasingly inadequate in this dynamic landscape.

This necessitates a paradigm shift towards more sophisticated, data-driven approaches capable of capturing the intricate spatial dimensions of risk. Geographic Information Systems (GIS) have emerged as a powerful solution. GIS empowers insurers to move beyond generalized risk profiles and embrace a granular, location-specific understanding of vulnerability.

The Rising Tide of Risk

The frequency and severity of natural disasters are demonstrably on the rise. Climate change is exacerbating extreme weather events, leading to more intense hurricanes, prolonged droughts, devastating floods, and widespread wildfires.

These events not only inflict immense human suffering but also pose significant financial strain on the insurance industry, necessitating more accurate and proactive risk mitigation strategies. Beyond natural catastrophes, evolving geopolitical landscapes, cyber threats, and supply chain vulnerabilities further compound the challenges faced by insurers.

Shortcomings of Traditional Methods

Traditional insurance risk assessment often relies on aggregated data and simplified models that fail to account for the nuanced spatial relationships that influence risk. These methods may overlook critical factors such as proximity to floodplains, variations in building construction, or the presence of mitigating infrastructure.

Such limitations can lead to inaccurate risk pricing, inadequate coverage, and ultimately, financial instability for insurers. The reliance on broad averages also obscures the disproportionate impact of risks on vulnerable communities, hindering the development of equitable and targeted insurance solutions.

GIS: A Technology Tailored for Risk

GIS technology offers a transformative approach to risk assessment by enabling the integration and analysis of diverse geospatial data. By overlaying layers of information – such as hazard maps, property records, demographic data, and infrastructure networks – GIS provides a comprehensive view of risk exposure and vulnerability.

GIS enables insurers to conduct sophisticated spatial analyses, identify high-risk zones, and quantify potential losses with greater precision. This granular level of insight allows for more accurate risk modeling, improved underwriting decisions, and optimized claims management processes.

A Thesis for Transformation

GIS is fundamentally transforming insurance risk assessment by enabling more accurate risk modeling, improved underwriting practices, and optimized claims management. It provides the framework for understanding spatial dependencies, incorporating diverse data sources, and ultimately, building a more resilient and sustainable insurance industry. This paradigm shift will empower insurers to navigate the complexities of a changing world and provide greater financial security to their customers.

Core GIS Concepts for Insurance

The insurance industry stands at a critical juncture, facing unprecedented challenges from a confluence of escalating natural disasters, the accelerating impacts of climate change, and the emergence of novel and complex risks. Traditional methods of risk assessment, often reliant on historical data and broad generalizations, are increasingly inadequate. To navigate this evolving landscape, insurers are turning to Geographic Information Systems (GIS), a powerful suite of tools and techniques that provide a spatially-explicit understanding of risk. Mastering the core concepts of GIS is paramount for insurance professionals seeking to leverage its full potential.

Geospatial Analysis: Unveiling Risk Patterns

Geospatial analysis forms the bedrock of GIS applications in insurance. This encompasses a range of techniques used to analyze spatial data, uncover hidden patterns, and understand relationships between geographic locations and associated attributes.

By overlaying various datasets – such as flood zones, property locations, and demographic information – geospatial analysis reveals critical insights into risk concentrations. This allows insurers to move beyond simplistic geographic averages and identify specific areas with elevated risk profiles. This granular understanding of risk patterns is essential for informed decision-making.

Spatial Statistics: Quantifying Risk Concentrations

Spatial statistics provides the mathematical rigor to quantify observed spatial patterns. Techniques like cluster analysis and spatial autocorrelation measure the degree to which risks are concentrated in specific locations.

Hot spot analysis, for example, can identify areas with statistically significant clusters of claims. This knowledge allows insurers to proactively address underlying risk factors in these high-risk zones.

Risk Modeling: Refining Pricing and Capital Allocation

Risk modeling leverages GIS to create sophisticated representations of potential losses. By integrating geospatial data with statistical models, insurers can simulate the impact of various hazards on their portfolios.

These models consider not only the likelihood of an event but also the potential severity and spatial extent of damage. This enables more accurate risk pricing and informs optimal capital allocation strategies.

Hazard Mapping: Visualizing Disaster Prone Areas

Hazard mapping is a critical component of GIS-based risk assessment, visually depicting areas susceptible to specific disasters.

These maps integrate data on floodplains, wildfire-prone vegetation, seismic activity, and other natural hazards. By overlaying these maps with property locations, insurers can quickly assess the potential exposure of their insured assets.

Examples of Hazard Mapping

• Flooding: Delineating flood zones and assessing the potential inundation depth for properties.

• Wildfires: Identifying areas with high vegetation density and proximity to ignition sources.

• Hurricanes: Mapping coastal areas vulnerable to storm surge and high winds.

• Earthquakes: Identifying fault lines and estimating ground shaking intensity.

• Tornadoes: Assessing the frequency and intensity of tornado touchdowns in different regions.

• Hailstorms: Mapping areas prone to hailstorms and assessing potential damage to roofs and vehicles.

• Landslides: Identifying unstable slopes and assessing the risk of landslides affecting properties.

• Drought: Mapping areas experiencing prolonged periods of drought and assessing the impact on agriculture.

Exposure Assessment: Identifying Assets at Risk

Exposure assessment involves determining the specific assets and populations that are at risk from various hazards. This includes not only the physical location of properties but also their characteristics, such as building type, construction materials, and occupancy.

GIS facilitates this process by integrating parcel data, building footprints, and demographic information. This provides a comprehensive view of the assets at risk and their potential vulnerability.

Vulnerability Analysis: Evaluating Susceptibility to Damage

Vulnerability analysis goes beyond exposure assessment to evaluate the susceptibility of assets to damage from specific hazards.

This considers factors such as building codes, construction quality, and the presence of mitigation measures. By combining exposure and vulnerability data, insurers can gain a more realistic understanding of potential losses.

Loss Estimation: Projecting Financial Impacts

Loss estimation utilizes GIS and risk models to project the potential financial losses from various disaster scenarios. This involves estimating the number of properties that are likely to be damaged, the extent of damage, and the cost of repairs or replacement.

Accurate loss estimation is crucial for setting premiums, managing reserves, and ensuring the financial solvency of insurance companies.

Predictive Analytics: Anticipating Future Events

Predictive analytics leverages historical data, spatial patterns, and statistical models to anticipate future events and potential losses. This includes forecasting the frequency and severity of natural disasters, identifying emerging risk areas, and predicting claim patterns.

By anticipating future events, insurers can proactively mitigate risks, optimize resource allocation, and improve customer service.

Catastrophe Modeling (CAT Modeling): Simulating Large-Scale Disasters

Catastrophe (CAT) modeling is a specialized application of GIS used to simulate the impact of large-scale disasters, such as hurricanes, earthquakes, and floods. These models integrate data on hazard characteristics, building vulnerability, and insurance policy terms to estimate potential losses across an entire portfolio.

CAT modeling is essential for reinsurance companies and insurers with significant exposure in high-risk areas.

Location Intelligence: Integrating Spatial Insights into Business Decisions

Location intelligence encompasses the broader application of GIS to enhance business decision-making across various insurance functions. This includes using spatial data to optimize marketing campaigns, identify new market opportunities, and improve customer service.

By integrating spatial insights into their workflows, insurers can gain a competitive advantage and improve their overall performance.

GIS Applications Across the Insurance Lifecycle

The insurance industry stands at a critical juncture, facing unprecedented challenges from a confluence of escalating natural disasters, the accelerating impacts of climate change, and the emergence of novel and complex risks. Traditional methods of risk assessment, often reliant on historical data and broad generalizations, are proving inadequate in the face of these dynamic and spatially varied threats. GIS offers a transformative solution, providing insurers with the tools to understand and manage risk with unprecedented precision across the entire insurance lifecycle.

This section delves into the practical GIS applications across underwriting, claims management, and product development, highlighting how spatial analysis enhances each stage.

Underwriting: Precision Risk Assessment

Underwriting forms the bedrock of insurance, where accurate risk assessment is paramount for profitability and solvency. GIS empowers underwriters with the ability to move beyond traditional methods and embrace a spatially-aware approach to risk evaluation.

Location-Specific Hazard Data and Building Characteristics

GIS allows for the integration of diverse datasets related to hazards (flood zones, earthquake fault lines, wildfire risk areas) and property characteristics (building age, construction materials, occupancy type) to determine the specific risk profile of a property.

This detailed assessment enables more accurate premium pricing and risk selection. Ignoring this granularity could lead to underpricing high-risk properties and overpricing low-risk ones, undermining competitiveness and financial stability.

Geocoding and Address Verification

Geocoding, the process of converting addresses into geographic coordinates, is fundamental to accurately locating insured properties.

GIS ensures that properties are precisely located, resolving ambiguities and errors inherent in address data. Accurate address verification is vital for linking properties to relevant hazard data layers and ensuring policy coverage aligns with the physical location.

Leveraging Property Records and Data Sources

GIS integrates disparate data sources, including property records, tax assessments, and building permits, to provide a comprehensive understanding of building characteristics.

This includes information about building materials, roof type, and elevation, all of which contribute to assessing vulnerability to various perils. Having access to this holistic property view allows insurers to create a more accurate risk profile for the property.

Satellite Imagery and LiDAR Data Analysis

Satellite imagery and LiDAR (Light Detection and Ranging) data provide valuable insights into property and environmental characteristics that may not be readily available through traditional sources.

Satellite imagery can reveal vegetation density, building footprints, and land use patterns, while LiDAR provides detailed terrain and elevation data. This data is crucial for assessing flood risk, landslide susceptibility, and other location-specific hazards.

Claims Management: Efficient and Accurate Resolution

The claims management process often is the most visible aspect of insurance for customers. GIS tools can significantly improve efficiency, accuracy, and fraud detection during claims handling.

Mapping and Analyzing Claim Patterns

By mapping claim locations and analyzing spatial clusters, insurers can identify areas with high claim frequencies or severities.

This information can reveal underlying risk factors, such as aging infrastructure or inadequate building codes. Identifying these spatial trends allows insurers to proactively mitigate future losses.

Spatial Analysis for Fraud Detection

GIS plays a crucial role in detecting fraudulent claims by identifying suspicious patterns and anomalies.

For example, multiple claims originating from the same location or claims with unusual characteristics compared to neighboring properties can raise red flags. Spatial analysis can also reveal inconsistencies between reported damage and available imagery or hazard data.

Optimizing Claims Adjuster Deployment

Efficient deployment of claims adjusters is essential for providing timely service and managing claim costs. GIS can optimize adjuster assignments by considering location, workload, and expertise.

By analyzing the spatial distribution of claims, insurers can assign adjusters to minimize travel time and ensure that resources are allocated effectively.

Product Development: Tailored Insurance Solutions

GIS enables insurers to develop innovative products and pricing strategies that are tailored to specific geographic areas and risk profiles.

Designing Geographically-Targeted Insurance Products

GIS allows insurers to design insurance products that address the unique needs and risks of specific geographic areas.

For example, insurers can offer specialized flood insurance policies in flood-prone areas or wildfire insurance policies in high-risk zones. This targeted approach ensures that customers receive coverage that is relevant to their specific circumstances.

Spatially-Explicit Premium Pricing

GIS facilitates the creation of spatially-explicit premium pricing models that reflect the actual risk at a given location.

By incorporating detailed hazard data, property characteristics, and historical claim data into pricing models, insurers can ensure that premiums accurately reflect the level of risk.

Addressing Climate Change Vulnerabilities

As climate change intensifies, insurers face increasing challenges in assessing and managing climate-related risks.

GIS provides the tools to analyze climate change vulnerabilities and develop insurance solutions that address these emerging threats. This includes modeling the impacts of sea-level rise, extreme weather events, and changing precipitation patterns. By understanding the spatial dimensions of climate risk, insurers can offer targeted solutions to help communities adapt and build resilience.

Key Data Sources and Technologies for GIS in Insurance

GIS Applications Across the Insurance Lifecycle.
The insurance industry stands at a critical juncture, facing unprecedented challenges from a confluence of escalating natural disasters, the accelerating impacts of climate change, and the emergence of novel and complex risks. Traditional methods of risk assessment, often reliant on historical data and simplified models, are proving inadequate to fully capture the nuances of today’s dynamic risk landscape. To effectively navigate this complexity, insurers are increasingly turning to sophisticated technologies and robust data sources, with Geographic Information Systems (GIS) at the forefront of this transformative shift.

This section delves into the core data sources and essential GIS software platforms that are empowering the insurance industry to make more informed decisions, enhance risk modeling, and improve overall operational efficiency.

Core Data Sources

The effectiveness of any GIS application hinges on the quality and relevance of the underlying data. In the context of insurance, a diverse range of geospatial data sources are crucial for understanding, assessing, and mitigating risk.

Satellite Imagery

Satellite imagery provides a broad overview of environmental conditions, land use patterns, and areas affected by natural disasters.

Platforms like Landsat, Sentinel, and commercial options such as WorldView offer imagery at varying resolutions, enabling insurers to monitor vegetation health, track urban development, and assess the extent of damage following catastrophic events.

Satellite imagery can be used for change detection, identifying areas of deforestation, urban sprawl, or coastal erosion that may impact insurance risk.

LiDAR (Light Detection and Ranging)

LiDAR technology uses laser pulses to create highly detailed 3D models of the Earth’s surface. This is invaluable for flood modeling, as it allows for precise mapping of elevation and terrain.

LiDAR data can also be used to assess building vulnerability by analyzing roof structures, building footprints, and proximity to potential hazards.

Furthermore, LiDAR is critical in mapping landslide susceptibility, especially in mountainous regions where traditional surveying methods are challenging.

Digital Elevation Models (DEMs)

Digital Elevation Models (DEMs) represent the bare-earth elevation of a terrain, providing a foundational dataset for various GIS analyses. DEMs are used extensively in hydrological modeling to simulate water flow and predict flood inundation areas.

They also play a vital role in hazard mapping by identifying areas prone to landslides, avalanches, and other terrain-related risks.

DEMs are often derived from LiDAR data or other remote sensing techniques.

National Flood Hazard Layer (NFHL)

The National Flood Hazard Layer (NFHL), maintained by the U.S. Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), provides authoritative flood risk information for communities across the United States.

Insurers utilize NFHL data to determine flood zones, assess flood insurance premiums, and understand the potential impact of flooding on insured properties.

The NFHL is regularly updated to reflect changes in floodplains and evolving flood risks.

S. Geological Survey (USGS) Data

The U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) offers a wealth of data related to earthquakes, volcanoes, landslides, and other natural hazards.

This includes information on seismic activity, fault lines, volcanic eruptions, and landslide-prone areas.

Insurers leverage USGS data to assess the risk of damage from these hazards and to develop appropriate risk mitigation strategies.

NOAA (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration) Data

The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) provides critical weather and climate data, essential for predicting and understanding extreme weather events.

This includes information on hurricanes, tornadoes, severe storms, droughts, and heatwaves.

Insurers use NOAA data to assess the likelihood and potential impact of these events, helping them to develop effective risk models and inform underwriting decisions.

Property Records

Property records, including parcel data and building characteristics, are foundational for assessing individual property risk.

These records provide information on building age, construction type, square footage, occupancy, and other factors that influence vulnerability to damage.

Integrating property records with geospatial data allows insurers to assess risk at a granular level and tailor insurance products to specific property characteristics.

Historical Claim Data

Historical claim data is a valuable resource for understanding past risk patterns and improving predictive models.

By analyzing the spatial distribution of past claims, insurers can identify high-risk areas, detect fraud, and refine their risk assessment methodologies.

Historical claim data, when combined with other geospatial datasets, can provide insights into the factors driving insurance losses.

Key GIS Software Platforms

To effectively utilize these diverse data sources, insurers rely on sophisticated GIS software platforms that provide the tools for data management, spatial analysis, and visualization.

Esri ArcGIS

Esri ArcGIS is a comprehensive GIS platform that offers a wide range of capabilities for geospatial analysis, data management, and mapping.

ArcGIS provides tools for creating and analyzing spatial data, building risk models, and visualizing insurance risk.

It is the industry-leading software for creating, analyzing, visualizing, and disseminating geospatial data.

QGIS

QGIS is a powerful open-source GIS software platform that offers a robust set of analytical capabilities. It provides users with a free and flexible alternative to commercial GIS software.

QGIS supports a wide range of data formats and offers a variety of plugins that extend its functionality.

Google Earth Engine

Google Earth Engine is a cloud-based platform for large-scale geospatial analysis. It provides access to a vast archive of satellite imagery and other geospatial datasets.

Google Earth Engine is particularly well-suited for monitoring environmental changes, assessing disaster impacts, and conducting research on climate change and its effects on insurance risk.

Remote Sensing Software

Remote sensing software, such as ENVI, ERDAS Imagine, and SNAP, is used for processing and analyzing remote sensing data, including satellite imagery and aerial photography.

These software packages provide advanced tools for image classification, feature extraction, and change detection. They enable insurers to derive valuable information from remote sensing data.

The Players: Organizations Leveraging GIS for Insurance

GIS Applications Across the Insurance Lifecycle.
The insurance industry stands at a critical juncture, facing unprecedented challenges from a confluence of escalating natural disasters, the accelerating impacts of climate change, and the emergence of novel and complex risks. Traditional methods, while valuable, often lack the granular spatial context required to effectively assess and manage these evolving threats. This necessitates a collaborative ecosystem of diverse organizations, each playing a crucial role in leveraging Geographic Information Systems (GIS) to enhance risk management capabilities.

Insurance Companies: Integrating GIS into Core Operations

Insurance companies are at the forefront of GIS adoption, integrating the technology into virtually every aspect of their operations. From underwriting and risk assessment to claims management and product development, GIS provides a powerful lens through which to view and understand spatial relationships.

They use GIS to assess property-specific risk based on location, proximity to hazards, and building characteristics. Geocoding and address verification are crucial for accurately locating properties, while spatial analysis allows for identifying areas of high risk concentration.

Claims departments leverage GIS to analyze claim patterns, detect fraudulent activities, and optimize the deployment of adjusters. Product development teams use GIS to design targeted insurance products tailored to specific geographic areas and risk profiles, resulting in more accurate pricing and reduced exposure.

Reinsurance Companies: Managing Catastrophic Risk with Spatial Insight

Reinsurance companies, responsible for absorbing large-scale losses, rely heavily on GIS for catastrophe (CAT) modeling and risk transfer. They utilize GIS to analyze the potential impact of catastrophic events, such as hurricanes, earthquakes, and floods, across vast geographic areas.

This allows them to accurately assess their exposure and effectively distribute risk across their portfolio. GIS-based CAT models incorporate a wide range of spatial data, including hazard maps, exposure data, and vulnerability assessments, to provide a comprehensive view of potential losses. The ability to visualize and analyze these risks spatially is critical for managing their financial stability.

Actuarial Associations: Promoting GIS Expertise

Professional actuarial associations, such as the Casualty Actuarial Society (CAS) and the Society of Actuaries (SOA), play a pivotal role in promoting the use of GIS within the actuarial profession.

They offer educational resources, training programs, and research initiatives to equip actuaries with the skills and knowledge needed to effectively integrate GIS into their work. By promoting GIS expertise, these associations contribute to the development of more sophisticated and data-driven risk management practices within the insurance industry. This, in turn, enhances the accuracy and reliability of insurance pricing and reserving.

Catastrophe Modeling Firms: Specialized Spatial Risk Analysis

Catastrophe modeling firms, such as RMS, AIR Worldwide, and CoreLogic, are specialized providers of sophisticated risk models and data for the insurance industry. They leverage GIS as a core component of their modeling platforms, integrating vast amounts of spatial data to simulate the potential impact of catastrophic events.

These firms offer a range of services, including hazard modeling, exposure assessment, vulnerability analysis, and loss estimation. Their models provide insurance companies and reinsurance companies with the information they need to understand and manage their exposure to catastrophic risk.

Government Agencies: Providing Foundational Geospatial Data

Government agencies, such as the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) and the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS), are critical providers of foundational geospatial data used by the insurance industry.

FEMA provides flood hazard maps and data through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP), which are essential for assessing flood risk and underwriting flood insurance policies. The USGS provides data on earthquakes, volcanoes, landslides, and other natural hazards, which are used by insurance companies to assess and manage their exposure to these risks. The availability of accurate and reliable government data is crucial for effective risk management in the insurance industry.

[The Players: Organizations Leveraging GIS for Insurance
GIS Applications Across the Insurance Lifecycle.
The insurance industry stands at a critical juncture, facing unprecedented challenges from a confluence of escalating natural disasters, the accelerating impacts of climate change, and the emergence of novel and complex risks. Traditional method…]

Challenges, Future Trends, and Considerations

The integration of GIS into insurance is not without its hurdles. While the potential benefits are significant, realizing them requires careful consideration of several challenges, including data quality, regulatory compliance, and the effective adoption of emerging technologies. Furthermore, environmental and infrastructural factors play a crucial role in shaping future risk landscapes.

Data Quality and Availability

A fundamental challenge lies in the quality and availability of geospatial data. Accurate and reliable data is the bedrock of effective GIS-based risk assessment.

Disparities in data formats, resolutions, and accuracy across different sources can complicate integration efforts and lead to inaccurate risk models.

Addressing this challenge requires a concerted effort to standardize data formats, implement rigorous quality control procedures, and invest in high-resolution data acquisition.

Open data initiatives and collaborative data-sharing platforms can also play a vital role in improving data availability.

Navigating Regulatory Compliance

The use of location data in insurance raises significant regulatory considerations.

Compliance with data privacy regulations such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) is paramount.

These regulations impose strict requirements on the collection, processing, and storage of personal data, including location information.

Insurance companies must ensure that their GIS implementations adhere to these regulations and that they obtain informed consent from individuals before collecting or using their location data.

Ethical considerations regarding data usage are equally important. Transparency and fairness in the application of GIS-based risk assessments are essential to maintain public trust.

Integrating Emerging Technologies

The future of GIS in insurance hinges on the effective integration of emerging technologies such as digital twins, artificial intelligence (AI), and machine learning (ML).

Digital twins, which are virtual representations of physical assets, can provide real-time insights into risk exposures and enable proactive risk management.

AI and ML algorithms can be used to analyze vast amounts of geospatial data, identify risk patterns, and predict future losses.

These technologies can also automate various insurance processes, such as claims processing and fraud detection. However, the successful integration of these technologies requires careful planning, investment in skilled personnel, and a commitment to ethical and responsible AI practices.

Addressing Environmental Factors

The escalating impacts of climate change, deforestation, and urban sprawl are reshaping the risk landscape for insurers.

Climate change is increasing the frequency and severity of natural disasters, such as hurricanes, floods, and wildfires.

Deforestation and urban sprawl are exacerbating these risks by altering land cover and increasing exposure to hazards.

Insurance companies must incorporate these environmental factors into their risk models and develop strategies to mitigate their impacts. This may involve offering incentives for sustainable land management practices and investing in climate resilience measures.

The Role of Infrastructure

The age, materials, and proximity to hazardous sites of buildings and infrastructure significantly influence their vulnerability to damage from natural disasters.

Older buildings may not meet current building codes and may be more susceptible to damage.

The use of certain building materials, such as wood, can increase the risk of fire damage.

Buildings located near hazardous sites, such as floodplains or earthquake fault lines, face a higher risk of damage.

Insurance companies must consider these infrastructural factors in their risk assessments and adjust premiums accordingly. Investing in infrastructure improvements and promoting resilient building practices can help reduce risk and improve insurability.

So, the next time you hear about GIS and insurance in the same sentence, remember it’s not just about fancy maps. It’s about smarter, data-driven decisions that ultimately lead to a more resilient and secure future for everyone. Pretty cool, right?